Strategic Revision: New Citizenship Survey Supplants Old

July 19, 2010

By Brandon Dutcher

“Everyone is entitled to his own opinion,” goes an old saying attributed to Daniel Patrick Moynihan, “but not to his own facts.”

This is especially true in the world of think tankery, where credibility is the coin of the realm. People may disagree with OCPA’s opinions—and believe me, many people do—but it’s another matter altogether to have people questioning our facts.

According to an article which appeared in Perspective last year to coincide with Constitution Day (“Mourning Constitutional,” September 2009), fewer than three percent of Oklahoma’s high-school students could pass a U.S. citizenship test. The article was based on the results of a statewide survey OCPA had commissioned to determine the level of basic civic literacy (or illiteracy, as it turned out) among Oklahoma high-school students. To do the research, OCPA had hired a nationally known firm, Strategic Vision LLC, whose surveys had been cited by several national publications and had been ranked as some of the most accurate in the country.

But even as the September issue of Perspective was hitting mailboxes, controversy was beginning to swirl around Strategic Vision. In a September 23 rebuke, the American Association for Public Opinion Research (AAPOR) announced that “Strategic Vision LLC, an Atlanta-based company, repeatedly refused to release essential facts about polls it published prior to the 2008 presidential primaries in New Hampshire and Wisconsin.”

As for the survey of civic literacy in Oklahoma, Strategic Vision stands by its results. Are those results valid? We have our doubts. And because Strategic Vision has, disturbingly, failed to provide additional information we have requested from them, their survey results—formerly published in this space—have been removed from OCPA’s website.

OCPA has commissioned another statewide survey of civic knowledge, this time using SoonerPoll, an Oklahoma firm with an impeccable record of transparency and disclosure. (The firm also does polling for the Tulsa World, whose managing editor, Susan Ellerbach, affirms that SoonerPoll meets very high standards.)

The SoonerPoll survey was conducted for OCPA May 25–June 24, 2010 among 1,014 registered voters in Oklahoma who also attended high school in the state. For the results of this new survey, click here.

Send This Article to a Friend

< Go Back